Skip to content

Court rules in favour of Robinson Huron Treaty beneficiaries

First Nations, Crown move on to third phase of lawsuit over lack of treaty payment increases
Treaty presser
Batchewana First Nation Chief Dean Sayers speaks at a media conference held by the First Nations in the Robinson Huron Treaty to provide reaction to a December 2018 ruling that the provincial and federal governments are obligated to increase treaty annunities. Wiikwemkoong Chief Duke Peltier and lawyer Dave Nahwegahbow look on. File photo Northern Ontario Business

Justice Patricia Hennessey has ruled in favour of Robinson Huron Treaty beneficiaries in the second phase of a lawsuit launched by 21 First Nations against the federal and provincial governments over treaty annuity payments.

Hennessy ruled in December 2018 during phase one of the hearings that both Canada and Ontario had failed to live up to its obligations to increase annuity payments over time as mineral and forestry resources were being developed.  

The annual treaty payment - which currently sees each beneficiary receive $4 annually - hasn’t increased since 1874. 

"This century-old dispute between the federal and provincial Crowns is one of the reasons why no increase has been made to the annuities for over 150 years," said Hennessy in the phase two decision. "This delay has had enormous negative consequences for the plaintiffs, not the least of which is the cost and complications of litigating this dispute based on two centuries of evidence. It is the stage on which this dispute plays out." 

The Ontario goverment has appealed the phase one decision, while the federal government decided not to appeal.  

"The case will continue on to phase three to deal with the issue of compensation," reads a press release issued by the Robinson Huron Treaty Trust Fund. "The case will also be heard in the Ontario Court of Appeal based on Ontario’s appeal of the phase one decision. The federal government did not join in the appeal."

"The Lake Huron leadership is again requesting the Government of Ontario to abandon their appeal, and for Prime Minister Trudeau and Premier Ford to do the honourable thing and start good faith negotiations, and not use covid-19 as an excuse to continue to do nothing."

The Robinson Huron Treaty - originally signed Sept. 9, 1850 at Whitefish Island in present-day Sault Ste. Marie - saw 37,500 square miles of land transferred to the Crown. 

James Hopkin

About the Author: James Hopkin

James Hopkin is a reporter for SooToday based in Sault Ste. Marie
Read more