Weather

Current Conditions
-10.4 C
Ice Fog
Today's Forecast
-3 C
A mix of sun and cloud
Sponsored by Highland Ford

News And Views

Classifieds

Announcements

Entertainment

Shop Local

More Local

Search The Web

Google Search

Green

Has PETA’s provocative autism campaign gone too far?

Friday, June 06, 2014   by: Greener Ideal

By 

PETA faced criticism for their 2008 campaign linking dairy consumption to worsened autism symptoms, and their undated article on the topic is enjoying a revival of media attention. It’s easy to see how this happened. The current debate on whether vaccinations have any effect on autism invites deep research on the subject, and the ubiquitous “gluten-free” craze is another hot topic these days (gluten has also been thought to exacerbate symptoms of autism). Delving far enough down the rabbit hole, you’ll find this “retro” writeup.

Let’s face it: PETA has a pretty obvious agenda, and it’s clear that their campaign’s aim is to promote a vegan lifestyle. Any sincere compassion for people with autism is tangential to their main focus. In 2008, this campaign parodied the played-out “Got Milk?” slogan with a provocative billboard asking, “Got Autism?” The advertising company hosting the billboard soon pulled it from its Newark, NJ location, but the image is still available on the PETA website.

peta autism billboard

 

News outlets and popular blogs such as Forbes, io9 and The Telegraph are mocking PETA’s claims and dismissing them as the scaremongers they admittedly are. PETA does cite peer-reviewed research, but these studies were cherry picked from many that found no link between consumption of cow’s milk and/or gluten and worsened autism symptoms. One study had a small sample size, while the other is nearly 20 years old. PETA also shares a mother’s testimonial:

Then I realized that Miles’ ear infections had begun when he was 11 months old, just after we had switched him from soy formula to cow’s milk. He’d been on soy formula because my family was prone to allergies, and I’d read that soy might be better for him. I had breast-fed until he was 3 months old, but he didn’t tolerate breast milk very well—possibly because I was drinking lots of milk. There was nothing to lose, so I decided to eliminate all the dairy products from his diet. What happened next was nothing short of miraculous. Miles stopped screaming, he didn’t spend as much time repeating actions, and by the end of the first week, he pulled on my hand when he wanted to go downstairs. For the first time in months, he let his sister hold his hands to sing “Ring Around a Rosy.”

This mother’s testimonial reminds me of something I witnessed in a college “practicum in autism” course, where I met a child on a dairy-free, gluten-free diet, way before it was “cool.” This was before the PETA campaign, too, so for people in certain psychology circles, their propaganda is not unprecedented. The mother of this child found that his behavior improved on the special diet; his symptoms were less severe. The link goes back at least as far as 1979, when Dr. Jaak Panksepp observed that autistic individuals digested wheat and dairy inefficiently. In 1991, Dr. Kalle Reichelt took this research further, finding that autistic children’s urine contained peptides suspected to result from improper breakdown of dairy and gluten. Scientists believed these peptides could cross the brain-blood barrier of already-autistic individuals, causing an opioid effect.

We don’t always turn to peer-reviewed research when seeking health advice. Much of what we learn about treating illness comes from word of mouth, and we still trust some of the folk remedies we learned from family and friends, even if science doesn’t back it up. If trying a special diet works for some people, what is there to lose? PETA is an easy target for ridicule, but they’re not just making stuff up. The research in line with PETA’s agenda might be weak, but it hints that there might be something to the theory, at least enough to give it a try (with a doctor’s approval).

Comments
1
Note: Comments that appear on the site are not the opinion of SooToday.com. If you see an abusive post, please click the link beside the post to report it.
Asuna 6/8/2014 8:18:30 PM Report

PETA to me, is a bit crazy and they are quite ridiculous in the ads, I dislike a lot of the promotional campaigns they do and I don't agree shock factors work.
And Im vegan,
However, As a certified holistic nutritionist. I agree with autism there are outstanding numbers of children with better results switching from dairy products to better products, though I suggest almond, hemp, rice milk over soy.

And also reducing the gluten limit does indeed work better to improve children with autism.

There is also medical marijuana with no thc (they cant get high) and all CBD which indeed also helps completely.
(again children DONT GET HIGH )

Our current diets and food sources are absolutely terrible for us.
We all need to work towards healthy sustainable foods, that have limited ingredients and true natural ingredients over foods with ingredients that we cannot pronounce.

While a vegan or vegetarian diet is not for everyone I believe truly that what we eat is important and we all should eat more veggies from local sources and less red meats and less dairy products.
To promote better health for longer healthier lives.
I was expecting a giant bash from this article. I am quite happy to see the opposite.
Thank you for posting hopefully more people read it!
Advertising | Membership | Terms of Service | Privacy Policy | About SooToday.com | Contact Us | Feedback

Copyright ©2014 SooToday.com - All rights reserved